The beating death of 2-year-old Isaac Lethbridge in foster care exposes a stubbornly persistent pattern of failures in Michigan’s child welfare system, despite several attempts at reform. The overburdened system has seen the number of children in foster care rise steadily since the mid-1990s even as the state resources to handle them shrank. Isaac was the third young child to die under the state’s watch in the last 18 months.
Isaac Lethbridge is the third child to die violently in a Michigan foster or adoptive home in the past 18 months. Ricky Holland, a 7-year-old former foster child from Jackson County, was killed by his adoptive parents in July 2005 in the family’s home near Williamston in Ingham County.
Foster-care systems across the country are troubled. In many cases, it takes a death or a lawsuit to spur reform. Here is what is happening in other states:
Children’s Rights, a New York-based advocacy group, is suing Michigan’s child welfare system. Marcia Robinson Lowry, the organization’s executive director, cites these areas for which change is needed:
Michigan’s complex, labor-intensive child welfare system begins with a Child Protective Services worker investigating a complaint of maltreatment. The first decision: Is it abuse or neglect? Then: Should the child be removed from the home and placed with relatives or in a foster home?
Photos and music capture the life of Isaac Lethbridge, courtesy of his family.
All the warnings were there that 2-year-old Isaac Lethbridge was in trouble at a Detroit foster-care home. But everyone ignored them until after the toddler was beaten to death. A Free Press examination found irregularities in how the foster parent was licensed — and complaints alleging mistreatment of children that failed to raise alarms.
The Lethbridge children’s journey did not end with Isaac’s brutal death.
Isaac Lethbridge and his sister weren’t the only children the Lula Belle Stewart Center failed. In early 2006, Betty Robins’ complaints sparked an investigation that should have signaled another alert about the agency.
The families who adopted six of the Lethbridge children are deeply disturbed by what happened to Isaac. Daisy Tomlin of Detroit, who adopted Ashleigh, the oldest, several years after taking her as a foster child, regrets not having been able to take one of her siblings.
Isaac Lethbridge traveled a painful journey in his 2 1/2 years. He was neglected by his parents, moved through three troubled foster homes in less than a year and was dead by last Aug. 16, beaten and burned, his collarbone broken. A Free Press special report shows there were many chances to save Isaac. But no one did.
Despite several licensing violations by the Lula Belle Stewart Center and a 2004 state report that criticized the agency over the beating death of a 4-year-old foster child that year, the Michigan Department of Human Services renewed the Detroit-based agency’s license to place children in 2005.
The state Department of Human Services on Tuesday shut down a private nonprofit foster care program that had placed a 2-year-old boy in a Detroit home where police say he was beaten to death last week.
October 4, 2006
The family of a 2-year-old boy beaten to death in a Detroit foster home in August has filed a federal lawsuit against the Lula Belle Stewart Center, the private foster care agency that licensed the home and was responsible for monitoring it.
September 20, 2006
After the Aug. 16 killing of a 2-year-old boy in a foster home licensed through the Lula Belle Stewart Center in Detroit, a team of seven state child abuse investigators took a closer look at how the agency was caring for its 106 other foster children. What the investigators found was startling:
August 29, 2006
Just 12 days before 2-year-old Isaac Lethbridge died of a beating in a Detroit foster home, two social services workers let his foster mother keep the boy despite noting that he was covered with “greenish, blue and black” bruises and had two black eyes.
August 27, 2006
Nine people — three children under age 4, a 12-year-old girl, three teenagers and two adult women — were present in a Detroit home when a young foster child was severely beaten and burned last week, according to court records from a hearing Friday. But Detroit police still don’t know who killed 2-year-old Isaac Lethbridge.
The death of a 2-year-old foster child was ruled a homicide Friday after Wayne County medical examiners determined the boy had been struck by a blunt object. Isaac Lethbridge died Wednesday at Children’s Hospital of Michigan after he stopped breathing in a Detroit foster home. Detroit police were investigating and no arrests had been made.
The attorney for a Detroit foster mother under scrutiny after a 2-year-old foster child died in her care this week said Thursday that his client has no idea why or how the child died. “She feels horrible about what happened,” attorney Marc Shreeman said of Charlise Rogers. “She doesn’t know what happened.”
Manslaughter and child abuse charges filed Tuesday against a Detroit woman in the beating death of her 2-year-old foster child were the latest dramatic turn in a case exposing flaws in the state’s child welfare system.
The death of a 2-year-old foster child was ruled a homicide Friday after Wayne County medical examiners determined the boy had been struck by a blunt object. Isaac Lethbridge died Wednesday at Children’s Hospital of Michigan after he stopped breathing in a Detroit foster home. Detroit police were investigating and no arrests had been made.
August 18, 2006
The attorney for a Detroit foster mother under scrutiny after a 2-year-old foster child died in her care this week said Thursday that his client has no idea why or how the child died. “She feels horrible about what happened,” attorney Marc Shreeman said of Charlise Rogers. “She doesn’t know what happened.”
January 10, 2007
Manslaughter and child abuse charges filed Tuesday against a Detroit woman in the beating death of her 2-year-old foster child were the latest dramatic turn in a case exposing flaws in the state’s child welfare system.